Feeling down? Feeling tired?
OH EM GEE — me too! And apparently so is everyone, as evidenced by the pervasive consumption of the most down-turner-arounding, tired-upside-downing, fat-firing drug around: Caffeine.
If it seems like the modern diet is over-saturated with caffeine, it’s because it is — but unfortunately it only gets worse with the subject of this review, which has nearly twice the caffeine content of traditional coffee.
But it’s cool, man: It also has a few brain healthy antioxidants & stuff, so you can kind of feel good about this caffeine source.
How Guarana Is Supposed to Work
The more I do these reviews, the more I realize how much caffeine I consume in a daily. Because not only do I drink coffee (I mix it with L-theanine, doggs — I promise I’m LEGIT) but I also consume guarana nearly regularly — at least as often as I workout, which is admittedly inconsistent.
Compared to coffee beans (1 – 2% caffeine concentration), guarana has virtually twice the caffeine content at 3 – 7% caffeine concentration. Although, to my credit, and to everyone else who supplements guarana, the herb isn’t just a caffeine source. Guarana’s non-caffeine bioactive constituents:
And opposed to caffeinated substances that don’t have these compounds (coffee), guarana possesses a healthy neuroprotective edge worth checking out.
As far as nootropic users are concerned, the primary benefit of supplementing guarana is for the reliable, potent bursts of mental & physical energy — stimulation that theoretically results from the following bio-mechanisms:
Central Nervous System Stimulation
Guarana stimulates the central nervous system largely because caffeine stimulates the central nervous system, however it’s not the only compound in guarana with CNS stimulatory effects — other xanthines such as guarana’s theophylline & theobromine have been described as having “caffeine-like” effects, and thus theoretically contributing to guarana’s better-than-coffee stimulation. Even so, we can chalk most of this bio-effect up to caffeine.
In my Caffeine as a Nootropic review (link below) I covered the nootropic advantages of supplementing caffeine, which are believed to stem from the drug’s stimulatory biomechanisms:
- Adenosine Receptor Inhibition
- Adrenal Activity Activation
- Dopamine Signalling Promotion (High Dose)
The sum total leads to enhanced energy, physical & mental performance, etc. Of course, caffeine isn’t the best nootropic (it actually disqualifies as a nootropic in my book for its cheap, easy cognitive boosts that sometimes impair cognitive function), but if used right it may reliably serve your nootropic needs. More on Caffeine.
Again, this bio-effect is largely ascribed to guarana’s caffeine. However, caffeine combined with guarana’s other active ingredients seem to enhance energy metabolism by: increasing fat oxidation, enhancing energy expenditure, & increasing exercise performance. While most users value this effect for its PWO/fat loss potential, the increase on energy metabolism also benefits the brain, which consumes about a fifth of the body’s energy.
One study found guarana extract at two concentrations (0.312 and 0.625 mg/mL) was able to protect dopaminergic cells treated with a neurotoxin (rotenone) at the lower dosage, demonstrating reductions in lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) leakage and stronger cell integrity. The study was unable to conclude which guarana constituents were responsible for the neuroprotective effects, however guarana’s antioxidant activity has elsewhere been linked to its procyanidin, catechin, & tannin content.
Why do we drink coffee? For energy, alertness, mood enhancement, weight loss management… Why do we supplement guarana? For energy, alertness, mood enhancement, weight loss management… What’s the common denominator?
Caffeine. The reason we drink coffee, the reason we drink guarana, the reason we do anything anymore is caffeine. Likely, it’s coursing through your veins right now — inhibiting those adenosine receptors, filling your bladder. However, that’s not all guarana is good for (but it is the primary benefit of supplementing guarana) as the herb also carries caffeine-like substances that are valued for their …well, their similarities to caffeine.
Even so, guarana makes for a healthier, antioxidant alternative to coffee & standalone caffeine, so don’t toss it completely by the wayside just yet.
Researchers Have Suggested Guarana Might:
Provide additional stimulation over caffeine alone (planarian model)
That’s right: planarians, the tiny flatworms primarily found in water — so take this study with a grain of salt. The measurements used to determine the stimulatory effects of guarana as compared to standalone caffeine were the locomotor activity and convulsive response of the planarians to substance exposure. And as you may have guessed from the header above, the researchers found “that guarana seeds provide additional stimulation over caffeine alone, and [they] document[ed] the changes to this stimulation in the context of both caffeine and glucose.”
Improve cognitive performance & alertness
This double-blind, placebo-controlled study tossed the planarians for full-fledged humans, viz. 28 healthy young adults aged 18-24, and assigned them to separate groups: A) 75 mg guarana extract (~12% caffeine), 200 mg Panax ginseng (G115), guarana + ginseng (75 mg, 200 mg, respectively), & placebo. On each study day cognitive performance & subjective mood were assessed pre-dose and various times post-dose, with the results indicating improvements in all three groups as compared to placebo. Guarana in particular was found to improve attention, yet demonstrated some reduction in test accuracy. Interestingly, the researchers concluded: “Given the low caffeine content (9 mg) of this dose of guarana extract, the effects are unlikely to be attributable to its caffeine content.”
Increase brain activity for better attention & mood
Observing a small sample size (20 adults) than the previous study’s, this double-blind, placebo-controlled study administered placebo, Berocca® Performance, a guarana + multivitamin supplement, or Berocca® Boost, a multivitamin supplement (no guarana), to its participants, who underwent neurocognitive testing to determine the substances’ benefits on cognitive performance & mood. The results: cognitive performance & self-rated well being were higher in the guarana group, with the guarana group showing even higher brain activity than the Berocca w/o guarana group. The conclusion: “These data confirm the acute benefits of multivitamins with guaraná on mood and cognitive performance.”
Bonus: Guarana + Green Tea for Fat Loss
Even the Nootropic Geek has his moments of vanity (as evidenced by him speaking of himself in the 3rd person, that ol’ jokester). Guarana certainly helps stimulant cognitive performance much in the same way as caffeine — with some evidence saying the non-caffeine elements also benefit mental output. However, this study found the mixture of green tea + guarana extracts standardized to 200 mg and varying amounts of EGCG (90, 200, 300, & 400 mg) to have a beneficial outcome on energy expenditure, i.e., calories burned. The researchers concluded that “the EGCG-caffeine mixture should be considered as a good complement in a weight-loss programme.”
How to Take Guarana
- Anywhere from 75 – 1050 mg daily has been researched for benefits.
- The common suggestion: Between 200 – 800 mg daily for energy purposes.
- Standardized extract typically contains anywhere from 20 – 50% caffeine.
- Concentrated extract typically centers on a 4:1 potency.
- The Geek’s suggestion: Start with 50 mg, then move up from there. Guarana possesses a much higher caffeine concentration than coffee, so don’t overdo it right away — especially if you’re caffeine sensitive or/and concurrently consuming other caffeine sources.
My Experience with Guarana
I only supplement guarana as a part of my natural PWO stack, which in total includes:
- Guarana Seed Powder
- Rhodiola Rosea
- Ginkgo Biloba
- Panax Ginseng
- Eleutherococcus Senticosus
(To be honest, I’m quite proud of this DIY stack — but it’s a work in progress.)
Only a few times I’ve supplemented guarana as a standalone nootropic, but quickly gave it up for a couple trivial, petty reasons: A) I didn’t like the soggy, muddy texture guarana powder assumed in hot water, and B) It’s easier for me to stick to my coffee-caffeine routine — and frankly it’s much harder for me to give up coffee than it is for me to get into guarana.
Would I like to get into guarana? Yes.
Given how much I drink green tea, it seems smart to mix guarana with a cup every now & then. However, until then I’ll be limiting my guarana intake to my preworkout get-pumped stack — which sometimes doubles as my pre-writing get-grammared stack.
Is Guarana a Good Nootropic?
Ignoring what I just said in the “My Experience” section, I say Yes, guarana is a good nootropic, and that Yes, guarana is better than coffee.
The only reason I haven’t made the full transition is due to inertia & (in)availability: the extreme availability of coffee and the relative inavailability of raw guarana. Granted, I could easily order & stock up on guarana supplements, check out which customer reviews rate which supplement the highest and go from there, but I prefer my guarana in its raw powder form — it’s easier to mix with other nootropics & monitor my caffeine intake.
If you’re able, try the raw stuff. I take it before working out, occasionally before working & writing. In either scenario, it’s pretty awesome. But the guarana supplements are also purdy cool (and there are a lot of guarana supplement variants to choose from).
Overall Guarana Nootropic Power Rating