Listeners of Joe Rogan’s podcast will know that the ex-Fear Factor host is friends with Infowars‘ Alex Jones, the controversial conspiracy theorist who seems to pop in & out of headlines from time to time. I aim to put that friendship to the test by sizing up their associative nootropics side-by-side: Joe Rogan’s Alpha BRAIN versus Alex Jones’ Brain Force. Admittedly, neither supplement is all too impressive, though they’re both two of the most recognizable supplements in the nootropic brain health game. Personally, I favor Alpha BRAIN over Brain Force, though the former hides its formula beneath proprietary blends.
For more awesome nootropic supplements, read my:
Page Contents
Formula Design
In terms of ingredient choices, Brain Force & Alpha BRAIN have much in common. Powerful natural nootropics such as Bacopa Monnieri, Phosphatidylserine, L-Theanine, Huperzine-A, and Alpha-GPC are shared between the formulas, in addition to mood-booster Vitamin B6.
Yet, there remain a few key differences that set these products apart, namely in the underlying purposes of their overall formula designs:
Brain Force Plus Review: Infowars’ Anti-Mind Control
These days, Infowars is a divisive subject in the media. Regardless, the network’s intent on “freeing the mind” from all of the “toxic weapons” in our diet & culture seems genuine with this well-crafted, Earth-grown blend of nootropics that nourish the brain as much as they boost cognition.
Not that there aren’t any questionable ingredients in this stack–for instance: Theobromine, the non-nootropic “love drug” stimulant in chocolate, and Yerba Mate Powder, which reads like a potentially sneaky source of undocumented caffeine.
Even so, the ingredients listed above (that can also be found in Alpha BRAIN) provide a diverse range of brain benefits that may support cognitive performance for students, workers, & anyone else in need of extra brainpower.
Alpha BRAIN Review: Brain Wave & Chemical Support
There are three key functions supported by Alpha BRAIN, which are represented by the titles of the product’s proprietary blends:
- Flow: As in “brain flow,” namely alpha brain wave flow, which is associated with creative thinking & “relaxed wakefulness.”
- Focus: The mix of Alpha-GPC, Bacopa, & Hup-A supports focus-enhancing neurotransmitter status for boosted learning, memory, & cognition.
- Fuel: Via enhanced cerebral circulation & neuroprotective antioxidant pterostilbene.
Aside from these blends, the star ingredient in this stack is AC-11, a branded extract of Cat’s Claw, which is being touted as a nootropic, but currently lacks the research to validate this claim. Even so, I like its presence here for its exceptional potential in this formula. Read my in-depth review on Alpha BRAIN.
Unique Features
In my mind, when I imagine Brain Force & Alpha BRAIN sitting side-by-side, I actually imagine Joe Rogen standing next to Alex Jones — the de facto official faces of these products.
Many people lump these two in the same political basket and treat them as almost equally unmentionable taboos. (Alex Jones being the greater he-who-shall-not-be-named of the two.) When I look at the contents of the formulas, there isn’t much to set them apart, with the exception of a few unique features, including:
Brain Force Plus
- Vitamin B12: Not as nootropic as B6, but Brain Force deserves props for providing the superior methylcobalamin form of the vitamin.
- Yerba Mate Leaf Powder: As a caffeine source, Yerba Mate is better than coffee for its wide array of antioxidants. Yet I’m not huge on caffeine sources in nootropic stacks in general.
- Theobromine: Another interesting addition to the formula for its “stimulant” status. Theobromine & (possibly) caffeine aren’t ingredients I’d necessarily use while admonishing the “toxic weapons” in our diets.
- Brain Force Plus: The “Plus” version of this formula adds 6 capsules and swaps out Vinpocetine for Black Pepper, all for the same price. While I like Vinpocetine, I also like Black Pepper’s nutrient absorption benefits.
Alpha BRAIN
- AC-11® Cat’s Claw: Only Onnit has this specific Cat’s Claw extract, giving Alpha BRAIN a unique advantage overall nootropics–depending on the true nootropic potential of this herb.
- Oat’s Straw Extract: Works well with L-Theanine for further supporting alpha brain waves.
- L-Tyrosine: Solid addition to this formula, although I’d prefer the N-Acetyl-L-Tyrosine form.
- Pterostilbene: Potent antioxidant found in red wine, believed to be superior to the better known Resveratrol antioxidant.
Related: Best Nootropics for Anxiety
Potency & Quality
One thing that Alpha BRAIN needs to learn from Brain Force: transparency matters.
While Alpha BRAIN’s proprietary blends look solid enough, they do obscure the individual ingredient dosages for each nootropic, effectively (and deliberately) obscuring the formula’s effectiveness. This is typically one of the first things I look for in a nootropic supplement, so it’s never a good look, even for a well-regarded one as Alpha BRAIN, when they hide their ingredient dosages.
Yet, this doesn’t let Brain Force entirely off the hook. Just because I can see all of its ingredient dosages, doesn’t make them all automatically good. For instance, the 50 mg L-Theanine is weak sauce, leading me to believe that Alpha BRAIN might actually supply more of this powerful nootropic than Brain Force.
What’s more, Alpha BRAIN supplies double the vitamin B6 found in Brain Force. Not that this is a huge deal, but it’s potentially indicative of all-around greater potency on Alpha BRAIN’s side.
All in all, between Brain Force & Alpha BRAIN, the differences in potency & quality between these formulas can range anywhere from equal to Alpha BRAIN being better. Brain Force Plus has some dosages that could be improved. The latter needs to show its dosages. Yet, I simply have more faith in Alpha BRAIN, based on what I can see.
Value: Brain Force Plus vs. Alpha BRAIN |
|||
Price | Servings | Price Per Serving | |
Brain Force Plus | $39.95 | 18 | $2.22 |
Alpha BRAIN | $34.95 | 15 | $2.33 |
Take Note: At time of writing, Brain Force Plus is selling at half price at the Infowars store, making it the drastically cheaper option between the two. For both, I’m not too thrilled with their meager serving counts: 18 and 15, respectively. Both Brain Force Plus and Alpha BRAIN are being altogether cheap and inconvenient; however, there are different buying options that could lower their respective prices per serving, making either one a more reasonable, higher value choice.
Brain Force Plus or Alpha BRAIN: Which is better?
Brain Force Plus is better for mental energy.
This mental energy mostly comes by way of caffeine and theobromine stimulation, both of which (but especially the former) aren’t exactly the most innovative, in terms of nootropic brain boosting. However, combined with the brain healthy, focus enhancing ingredients, this mental energy seems manageable, if not beneficial to sustaining healthy mental production.
Alpha BRAIN is better for brain waves & chemicals.
Brain Force has L-Theanine, but Alpha BRAIN has L-Theanine & Oatstraw, providing more alpha brain wave support. Brain Force has Huperzine-A, but Alpha BRAIN has Huperzine-A & L-Tyrosine, providing more neurochemical support. In essence, Alpha BRAIN accomplishes all of the nootropic bio-benefits of Brain Force and then some.
My Recommendation
It’s difficult to talk about Brain Force Plus and Alpha BRAIN objectively, as both are backed by strongly contentious personalities. (Alex Jones more so than Joe Rogan.) But listen: I don’t really care about all that. All I care about are the supplements.
And frankly… neither are excellent nootropic supplements.
Nonetheless, I do recommend one stack over the other, simply for having more nootropics than other. I’m the Nootropic Geek, b*tch. I like nootropics. So I’m going to go with the formula that has more nootropics.
And that formula is: Alpha BRAIN.
Melissa Watson says
Great comparison and completely objective. I can appreciate that. Although, I was wondering which was better for people that have ADHD as a replacement for Adderall. If you had that information I would greatly appreciate it.
-M
Linda Matthews says
Is the oat straw gluten free? May explain headaches some get after using Alpha Brain for 3 months. If this is a problem, it would explain why such headaches may not go away right away (It takes about 3 months to get gluten out of your system.) I’ve also heard headaches more often occur with phosphadityl-serine levels over 300 – too bad we don’t know the answer to either question here.
The Geek says
Hey Linda,
That’s a good question. I believe Onnit lists Alpha BRAIN as a gluten-free formula, but I haven’t seen much in the scientific literature on oat straw that could tell us definitively. I agree: it’s frustrating when manufacturers hide their dosages beneath proprietary blends — might help to figure out what’s doing what in these formulas.
Thanks for the Q.,
Geek
Thank you for the in depth comparison. I currently take Mind Lab Pro but I am always looking at the other stacks……Loved your in-depth on Mind Lab Pro & Qualia!! Thanks again, RON
Would it ne benefitial to alternate Brain Focus Plus and Alpha Brain?
Hi Linda,
Not a bad idea, especially to get a better sense of which product works best for you. Both supplements carry Bacopa, which requires long-term supplementation to reach peak effect, so transitioning back and forth between formulas won’t impair the Bacopa benefits.
If you do alternate between Brain Focus Plus and Alpha Brain, I’d be interested to hear which one worked better for you.
Thanks for the Q.,
Geek
Thank you. I have been a Brain Force Plus user for a while ( it does work) but your analysis has led me to try Alpha Brain. Any extra edge is important. I will come back and let y’all know real world differences.
Thank you. Exactly what I was looking for.
Great review. Thanks for the well thought out arguents. For someone relatively new to nootropics this is important stuff.
Can you/do you have a review of chordycep mushrooms? Like rogans shroomtec vs…? Others?
Appreciate the read, and thanks for the input.
With regards to cordyceps, I’ve only researched that fungus in the context of enhancing testosterone & exercise. As far as I’ve seen, there isn’t much on their nootropic capacity, although their role in the ATP cycle might assist with brain energy/fatigue. Something I may consider reviewing in the future. Although, admittedly, natural cordyceps are pretty nasty to look at…
– The Geek